Quick Answer
Before filing an insolvency application against a company, an operational creditor must serve a demand notice under Section 8 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. Once the company receives that notice, it has 10 days to pay the debt or bring to the creditor’s notice the existence of a dispute. If neither happens, the creditor may file a Section 9 application before the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT). A genuine, pre-existing dispute is a complete defence to admission.
If you are an operational creditor owed money by a company, or you are a company that has just received a demand notice, the next 10 days determine your legal position. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) sets a tight, sequential timeline for this stage, and both sides make critical errors within the first week more often than at any later point in the process.
This guide sets out what a Section 8 demand notice is, the steps an operational creditor must follow before and after serving one, and what a company must do within 10 days to protect itself. We also cover the minimum default threshold, what happens at the NCLT, a side-by-side comparison of deadlines and risks, a first 7-day checklist for both sides, and the mistakes that most commonly weaken an otherwise strong case.
For a wider view of how this fits into the insolvency framework, see our IBC guide for businesses.
What is a Section 8 demand notice, and how does Section 9 follow?
Section 8 of the IBC requires an operational creditor to serve a demand notice on the corporate debtor as a mandatory precondition to filing a Section 9 application. The notice must be in Form 3 or Form 4 under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority) Rules, 2016.
Form 3 is used where the demand is made without accompanying an invoice. Form 4 is used where an unpaid invoice is the basis of the claim. Both forms are prescribed under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority) Rules, 2016, and each must contain specific particulars about the operational debt and the default.
Once the company receives the notice, Section 8(2) gives it 10 days to do one of two things: pay the unpaid amount, or reply in writing bringing to the creditor’s notice the existence of a dispute or the repayment of the unpaid operational debt. If the company does neither within 10 days, the operational creditor may file a Section 9 application before the NCLT, seeking to initiate the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP).
The Section 9 application is filed in Form 5, and must be accompanied by a copy of the demand notice, proof of its delivery, a copy of any reply received from the company, and an affidavit from the creditor. The bank certificate confirming non-receipt of payment, once prescribed separately as a mandatory annexure, is now treated as part of the affidavit or supporting documentation; confirm the current requirements under the applicable rules before filing.
What is a pre-existing dispute under the IBC, and why does it matter?
A pre-existing dispute is the most effective defence a company has against a Section 9 application at the admission stage. Under Section 8(2)(a), a company may bring to the creditor’s notice the existence of a dispute, if any, or the record of the pendency of a suit or arbitration proceedings filed before the receipt of such notice. The NCLT cannot admit a Section 9 application where such a dispute exists.
The Supreme Court’s decision in Mobilox Innovations Pvt. Ltd. v. Kirusa Software Pvt. Ltd. (2018) 1 SCC 353 settled the test the NCLT applies: the dispute must not be spurious, hypothetical or illusory. The existence of the dispute must be raised by the company in its Section 8(2) reply; a dispute that surfaces only after the Section 9 application is filed carries significantly less weight.
A company raising this defence must communicate it clearly and with documentary support within the 10-day window. Silence, or a vague reply without specifics, is not treated as raising a dispute under Section 8(2).
One precision point matters here. The dispute must be pre-existing, meaning it must have existed before the demand notice was received, not before the application was filed. Courts have examined this carefully, and invented or unsubstantiated disputes raised only to defeat an application are generally rejected.
What should an operational creditor do to serve a demand notice and file at the NCLT?
- Confirm the default meets the minimum threshold. The minimum amount of default for an operational creditor to file a Section 9 application is ₹1 crore, as currently fixed by the central government under Section 4 of the IBC. This figure is set by notification and can change; verify the current threshold before filing.
- Prepare the demand notice in Form 3 or Form 4. Use Form 3 where the demand is made without an invoice; use Form 4 where an unpaid invoice accompanies the claim.
- Serve the notice on the company’s registered office. Deliver the notice by hand, registered post, speed post, or electronic means as prescribed, and retain documentary proof of delivery.
- Wait out the 10-day period. The 10 days run from the date the company receives the notice, not from the date of dispatch. Filing a Section 9 application before this period expires is a procedural defect that can lead to rejection.
- Assess any dispute raised in the company’s reply. If the company replies within 10 days raising a pre-existing dispute, evaluate whether the dispute is genuine and pre-existing before deciding to proceed.
- Prepare and file the Section 9 application in Form 5. The application must include a copy of the demand notice, proof of delivery, the company’s reply (if received), and a supporting affidavit. File before the NCLT bench with jurisdiction over the company’s registered office.
- Ensure all annexures are complete. An incomplete Form 5 can be returned for refiling and the delay can affect your timeline.
A demand notice under Section 8 is a formal legal communication, and the form and content requirements matter. Our upcoming guide on drafting and sending a legal notice in India covers general principles for drafting such communications.
What should a company do after receiving a demand notice?
- Calendar the 10-day deadline from the date of receipt. The clock runs from receipt, not from the date printed on the notice.
- Check whether the debt is genuinely owed. Review the invoices, purchase orders, contracts, and payment records referenced in the demand notice.
- Gather evidence of any pre-existing dispute. Collect correspondence, quality complaints, pending arbitration records, or any other contemporaneous documentation showing the dispute predated the demand notice.
- Draft a Section 8(2) reply within 10 days. State clearly either that the amount has been paid, or that a dispute exists, with specific reference to documents and dates. The reply must be in writing and delivered to the creditor within 10 days.
- Consider settlement where the debt is genuinely due. Paying the undisputed amount, or negotiating a payment arrangement, can resolve the matter before it reaches the NCLT.
- Engage counsel before the 10-day period expires. A considered, evidence-backed reply is far more likely to succeed at the admission stage than a generic denial filed at the last moment.
- Prepare for a Section 9 filing if the creditor proceeds despite your reply. A documented, timely dispute becomes your primary defence at the NCLT admission stage.
A company facing recovery pressure from a secured lender rather than an operational creditor faces a different framework. Our guide on loan recovery under the SARFAESI Act and DRT explains how secured creditors enforce claims outside the IBC route.
Creditor vs company: first step, deadline, and key risk
Aspect | Operational creditor | Company (corporate debtor) |
First step | Serve demand notice in Form 3 or Form 4 under Section 8 of the IBC | Review the notice and note the 10-day reply deadline from the date of receipt |
Deadline | Must wait 10 days after the company receives the notice before filing at the NCLT | Must reply in writing within 10 days of receipt, paying the debt or raising a pre-existing dispute |
Key risk | Filing a Section 9 application that the NCLT rejects for a genuine pre-existing dispute, or filing with an incomplete Form 5, or before the ₹1 crore threshold is met | Missing the 10-day reply window, or raising a dispute too vaguely or without documentary support for the NCLT to treat it as genuine |
How does the NCLT process a Section 9 application?
The NCLT bench with territorial jurisdiction over the corporate debtor’s registered office examines the Section 9 application on admission. The Tribunal considers whether the application is complete in form and content, whether the default meets the minimum threshold, whether the operational debt and default are established, and whether the company has raised a genuine pre-existing dispute.
If the NCLT admits the application, it declares a moratorium under Section 14, appoints an interim resolution professional, and the company enters CIRP. The board’s powers are effectively suspended during this period and the interim resolution professional takes over management of the company’s affairs.
A company facing both a creditor claim and a shareholder dispute faces compounding governance pressure during this period. Our guide on oppression and mismanagement petitions at NCLT covers how those parallel proceedings interact.
What should you do in the first 7 days?
If you are the operational creditor
- Confirm the unpaid debt meets the ₹1 crore minimum threshold, as currently notified under Section 4 of the IBC.
- Prepare and serve the demand notice in Form 3 or Form 4 with proof of delivery.
- Set a reminder to check whether any reply is received within the 10-day window.
- Begin assembling the Form 5 application, so it is ready to file on day 11 if no reply or payment is received.
- Brief your advisor on the underlying contract, invoices, and any earlier communications with the company.
If you are the company
- Note the date of receipt and count 10 days forward.
- Pull every invoice, purchase order and communication relevant to the claimed debt.
- Search specifically for any correspondence, complaints, or legal proceedings that predate the demand notice and establish a live dispute.
- Decide, with your advisor, whether to pay, dispute, or negotiate.
- Send a written Section 8(2) reply before day 10, supported by documents.
What mistakes should operational creditors and companies avoid?
- Filing before the ₹1 crore threshold is met. An application for a default below the notified minimum under Section 4 of the IBC will not be admitted.
- Filing the Section 9 application before the 10-day period from receipt expires. The IBC is explicit: the creditor must wait for the 10-day window to close after the company receives the notice.
- Using the wrong form. Form 3 and Form 4 apply to different situations; using the incorrect form can result in procedural rejection.
- Filing an incomplete Form 5. Missing annexures, including the demand notice, proof of delivery, or the creditor’s affidavit, are common grounds for return or rejection.
- Raising a dispute without evidence. A company that asserts a dispute exists but cannot show it predates the demand notice will likely fail this defence at the NCLT.
- Missing the 10-day reply deadline. A company that stays silent within the 10-day window loses its primary statutory defence and leaves the creditor free to file.
- Treating the demand notice as a formality. Both sides underestimate how quickly the 10-day window closes and how little room there is to correct a late or incomplete response.
A company facing a Section 9 notice alongside a question about its registered status, or where its name has been struck off the MCA register, should address both issues together. Our guide on reviving a struck-off company at the NCLT explains that process.
Next steps if you are facing a Section 9 demand notice
Whether you are an operational creditor preparing to serve a demand notice or a company that has just received one, the first 10 days determine the strength of your position at the NCLT. Creditors need a complete, correctly formatted application with all required annexures. Companies need a documented, timely written reply that specifically identifies the pre-existing dispute and the evidence supporting it.
Costs for Section 9 matters depend on the complexity of the dispute, including how much evidence needs review and how many parties are involved. Contact Altacit Global at info@altacit.com for a review of your situation and a quote on request.
Frequently asked questions
Q1: What is a Section 9 demand notice?
A Section 9 demand notice is a shorthand for the demand notice served under Section 8 of the IBC. An operational creditor serves this notice on a corporate debtor in Form 3 or Form 4, demanding payment of an unpaid operational debt before filing a Section 9 application at the NCLT.
Q2: How many days does a company have to reply to an IBC demand notice?
Under Section 8(2) of the IBC, the company has 10 days from the date of receipt of the demand notice to pay the debt or reply in writing bringing the creditor’s notice of a dispute.
Q3: What is a pre-existing dispute under the IBC?
A pre-existing dispute is a genuine dispute over the operational debt that existed before the company received the Section 8 demand notice. Under Section 8(2)(a) of the IBC, the company may bring to the creditor’s notice the existence of such a dispute or any pending suit or arbitration proceedings. The Supreme Court’s decision in Mobilox Innovations Pvt. Ltd. v. Kirusa Software Pvt. Ltd. (2018) 1 SCC 353 confirmed that the dispute must not be spurious, hypothetical or illusory.
Q4: What is the minimum default amount for filing under Section 9?
The minimum amount of default required to file a Section 9 application is ₹1 crore, as currently fixed by government notification under Section 4 of the IBC. Verify the current notified threshold before filing, since this figure can be revised.
